New York
New York state tax preparation
New York has high state and city income taxes, the convenience-of-employer rule that catches remote workers, and the most aggressive residency audit program in the country. Solid preparation matters.
How does New York state and city income tax work?
New York has both a state income tax (top rate 10.9 percent) and, for residents and certain workers in New York City, a city income tax (top rate 3.876 percent). The combined top marginal rate exceeds 14 percent, which is above the 13.3 percent California top rate when fully stacked. New York also has the most aggressive residency audit program in the country.
What New York tax topics come up most?
- Form IT-201 personal income tax return. Filed by New York residents on all worldwide income.
- Form IT-203 nonresident or part-year resident return. Filed by nonresidents with New York-source income.
- NYC-1127 New York City income tax. Additional city tax for New York City residents and for certain employees of NYC-based government entities.
- Convenience-of-employer rule. New York's signature aggressive sourcing rule. Wages earned outside New York for a New York employer are taxed by New York unless the remote work is required by employer necessity (not employee convenience). This catches many remote workers.
- 183-day rule for statutory residency. A non-domiciliary maintaining a permanent place of abode in New York and spending more than 183 days in New York is a statutory resident, taxed on all worldwide income.
- Domicile residency. A New York domiciliary is a New York resident regardless of days, unless the safe-harbor exception applies.
- Pass-through entity tax (PTET) election. New York allows partnerships and S corporations to elect entity-level tax payment as a federal SALT-cap workaround.
- Capital gains. Taxed as ordinary income at New York's progressive rates, no preferential treatment.
- METRO commuter mobility tax. Additional tax on certain employers and self-employed individuals operating in the metropolitan commuter transportation district (NYC and surrounding counties).
The New York convenience-of-employer rule, explained
New York's convenience-of-employer rule is one of the most aggressive remote-work tax rules in the country. It taxes wages earned outside New York by employees of a New York employer, unless the remote work is required by the employer's necessity rather than the employee's convenience.
The rule originally targeted occasional out-of-state work by New York-based employees. Post-2020, New York has applied it to fully remote employees who never set foot in New York, taxing them as if all their wages were earned in New York.
The result: a remote worker living in Arkansas (or Florida, Texas, etc.) and working for a New York-based company may be required to file a New York nonresident return and pay New York tax on all wages, even though no work was physically performed in New York. The home state's credit-for-taxes-paid often does not fully offset the New York tax for residents of low-tax or no-tax states.
Specific facts matter. Employer policies, employment agreements, and the nature of the work all factor into whether remote work is for the employee's convenience or the employer's necessity. We work through the analysis on intake.
What if I am moving from New York?
New York is one of the most aggressive states in challenging residency departures. The Department of Taxation and Finance regularly audits former residents for 2-5 years post-move, looking for evidence that domicile was not properly changed.
Factors examined include: continued ownership of New York real estate (especially the family home), continued employment with a New York employer, family ties (spouse and children remaining in New York), location of professional advisors, location of medical care, days of physical presence in New York, and intent statements.
Successful residency departures from New York to a no-tax state typically involve: selling or converting the New York residence, ending New York employment or transferring to a non-New York office, moving family members, changing driver license and voter registration, and maintaining strict day counts. The bar is high; preparation matters more than intent.
New York tax FAQs
What is the top New York state income tax rate?
10.9 percent on income over $25 million as of 2024 (with brackets that have shifted recently). Combined with New York City's 3.876 percent top rate for NYC residents, the maximum stacked marginal rate is approximately 14.776 percent, the highest in the U.S.
Do I owe New York tax if I work remote for a New York company from another state?
Possibly, due to New York's convenience-of-employer rule. If you work remote for the convenience of yourself rather than the necessity of the employer, New York may treat your wages as New York-source income and require nonresident filing. Specific employer policies and employment terms factor into the analysis.
How many days can I spend in New York before becoming a statutory resident?
If you are not a New York domiciliary but maintain a permanent place of abode in New York and spend more than 183 days in New York during the year, you are a statutory resident and taxed on all worldwide income. Day counting must be careful, even partial days in New York can count under specific rules.
Can I move from New York to Florida and avoid New York tax?
Yes, but the change must be properly documented. New York aggressively audits residency departures. The cleanest moves involve selling the New York residence (or converting to a non-primary use), establishing Florida domicile through driver's license, voter registration, and primary home, ending New York employment or transferring to a non-New York office, and maintaining careful day counts. New York audits former residents for several years; documentation matters.
What is the New York City income tax?
New York City imposes an additional income tax on residents (and on certain commuters under specific rules). The top NYC resident rate is 3.876 percent. It applies on top of New York state income tax. Filed on Form NYC-1127 (or as part of IT-201 for residents).
Should my S corporation make the New York PTET election?
Probably yes, if the S corporation has New York-source income and the shareholders are subject to the federal $10,000 SALT deduction cap. The pass-through entity tax election lets the S corporation pay New York tax at the entity level (federally deductible) rather than passing it through to the shareholders' personal returns. The election timing rules are specific; we walk through them with eligible S corporations.
Related work and reading
Ready when you are
Start with a fifteen minute conversation. We will figure out the right fit together.